Newsom Wants Every Death Row Killer SPARED

Gavin Newsom speaks at a podium with U.S. and California flags behind him
Photo: Sheila Fitzgerald / Shutterstock

Newsom Hits Death Row Clemency Limit: What California’s Constitution Actually Allows

The single most important fact in California’s death-row commutation fight is not whether Governor Gavin Newsom opposes capital punishment — he has said so for three decades — but that the California Constitution itself splits his authority into two unequal halves, and only one half is his to exercise alone.

Key Points

  • Newsom’s November 5 letter commutes all 548 death sentences to life without parole, the largest mass clemency action in American history
  • Of those 548 cases, 166 fall entirely within the governor’s unilateral constitutional power; 382 require California Supreme Court approval with four justices concurring
  • Thirty county district attorneys and the Criminal Justice Legal Foundation have sued, arguing victims and prosecutors were never consulted before the announcement
  • The action converts death sentences to permanent imprisonment — it is not a pardon, and condemned prisoners are not released
  • Historically, mass commutations of entire death rows are rare but not unprecedented; California’s is the eighth such action in the modern death-penalty era

The Mechanism: Two Different Powers Wearing One Name

Article V, section 8(a) of the California Constitution gives the governor broad clemency authority — the power to grant a reprieve, pardon, or commutation after sentence. But that same section carves out an exception that is easy to overlook until it collides with a case like this one: a governor “may not grant a pardon or commutation to a person twice convicted of a felony” except on recommendation of the California Supreme Court, with four justices concurring. That single clause is the entire story. It means “commutation” is not one power but two — an unrestricted one for first-time felons, and a court-supervised one for repeat offenders.

Newsom’s office has acknowledged this split directly. Of the 548 people on death row, 166 do not carry a second felony conviction and can be commuted by the governor’s signature alone. The remaining 382 — roughly seventy percent — require the state’s highest court to review and recommend commutation before Newsom can sign anything binding. NBC News legal analyst Danny Cevallos noted that the court does not need unanimity, only a plurality of justices, which makes the outcome turn on the composition of the bench rather than a single up-or-down vote. Three of the court’s current members were themselves appointed by Newsom, a detail prosecutors have been quick to point out in arguing the review will not be the independent check the constitution intends.

What the Governor Actually Did, and What He Didn’t

It matters that this is a commutation, not a pardon. Newsom’s letter describes life without parole as “the most severe punishment I can lawfully impose and the state of California can ethically enforce” — language chosen to distinguish the action from clemency that frees someone outright. No one walks out of prison because of this order. The 548 men and women remain incarcerated for the rest of their lives; what changes is the method and legal possibility of their death, not the fact of their confinement. That distinction has not stopped the political temperature from rising, particularly because commutation, unlike a pardon, is also reversible in a way a pardon typically is not — a successor governor could decline to honor commutations still pending in court when Newsom leaves office, since the order for the 382 contested cases will not be final until the Supreme Court acts.

The letter frames the decision as the culmination of a position Newsom has held publicly since 2019, when he imposed a moratorium on executions and halted use of the state’s execution chamber. Supporters read the commutation as the logical endpoint of that moratorium: if the state will not carry out executions, maintaining death sentences indefinitely accomplishes little beyond prolonging litigation and uncertainty for everyone involved, including victims’ families who have waited through decades of appeals.

Where the Dispute Is Real: Notice, Not Just Law

The constitutional question of court approval for repeat felons is a known, bounded legal issue that will be resolved by the California Supreme Court on its own timetable. The sharper, more immediate conflict is procedural: did the governor’s office consult the prosecutors and victims whose cases are affected before announcing a blanket policy covering all 548 prisoners at once? On this point, the evidence from the governor’s critics is specific and names real people. Criminal Justice Legal Foundation president Anne Marie Schubert says her organization obtained documentation showing Newsom’s office released research, memos, and inmate lists but never contacted the district attorneys who originally prosecuted the cases. Los Angeles County District Attorney Nathan Hochman has made the contrast explicit, noting his own office personally reviewed more than fifty death-penalty-eligible cases and engaged victims’ families case by case before reaching any determination — the kind of individualized process Hochman argues a blanket commutation simply skips.

Thirty county district attorneys, organized with the Criminal Justice Legal Foundation, have filed suit in the California Supreme Court arguing the commutation violated victims’ statutory right to an “opportunity to be heard” before sentences are altered. Victims’ relatives have given the complaint a human face: Faye Jenkins, whose daughter and son-in-law were murdered in 2008, told reporters flatly, “We voted for this,” pointing to California’s repeated ballot-box affirmations of capital punishment. These are not vague objections. They name specific prosecutors, specific procedural requirements, and a specific statutory hook — which is why this dispute, unlike generic political criticism, deserves to be weighed as a genuine competing claim rather than dismissed as noise.

The Historical Pattern: Rare, But Not Without Precedent

Newsom’s action is the eighth blanket death-row commutation in the modern era of American capital punishment, and the largest in scale. Illinois Governor George Ryan commuted 167 death sentences in 2003 amid mounting evidence of wrongful convictions; Governor Pat Quinn cleared the state’s remaining 15 condemned prisoners in 2011 as Illinois formally abolished the practice. Researchers tracking capital clemency since 1976 count more than 300 commutations nationally, but only around 80 of them were individualized, case-by-case grants — the overwhelming majority were categorical actions by governors who had concluded, as Newsom has, that the system itself was no longer tenable to operate. Seen against that backdrop, California’s commutation is historically unusual mainly in raw numbers, not in form. What is comparatively unusual is the scale of the legal entanglement it now faces, given that no prior blanket commutation ran headlong into a constitutional carve-out affecting seventy percent of the affected population.

What Comes Next

The practical resolution now rests with the California Supreme Court, which must decide whether to recommend commutation for the 382 contested cases and, separately, whether the governor’s office satisfied its procedural obligations to prosecutors and victims before announcing the policy. Until that ruling lands, roughly a third of the 548 commutations are final, and the rest remain provisional — a legally incomplete promise rather than a settled outcome. Whatever the court decides, the episode has already clarified something enduring about executive clemency in capital cases: it is a genuine constitutional power, but in California it was deliberately built with a brake built in for exactly this kind of categorical exercise, and that brake is now being tested in public, case by case.

Sources:

nypost.com, gov.ca.gov, leginfo.legislature.ca.gov, cnn.com, da.lacounty.gov, bbc.com, news.bloomberglaw.com, abc10.com, cjlf.org